In Lisp is the function `1+` just syntactic sugar? -

-

i started learning lisp. 1 of first concepts grasp seems prefix notation (i.e. instead of writing "1 + 2", write "+ 1 2"). trying work out why 1+ function exists.

what reason prefer (+ 1 2) or (1+ 2)?

is syntactic sugar? code optimisation? readability?

perhaps there more complex function call examples show why 1+ function exists. insight appreciated.

do remember part of common lisp standardizing many implementations had. so, if many implementations had 1+ function, have been enough include it. rainer's answer quotes cltl2 on which implementations had (maclisp , lisp machine lisp). why implementations have had in first place? it's useful in loops, e.g., 

(do ((x 0 (1+ x)))     ((= x 10))   ; ...   )

that's place (+ x 1) have been fine, too. there lots of cases it's handy call kind of function indirectly, , it's easier (mapcar '1+ …) (mapcar (lambda (x) (+ 1 x)) …).

but that's it. adding 1 (or subtracting one; there's 1- well) such common operation it's handy have function it. if there's hardware support, might implementation can optimize, too. (although the documentation note "implementors encouraged make performance of [(1+ number) , (+ 1 number)] same.") since these functions available , used, they're way indicate intent. e.g., make typo , write (+ 1 x) when meant write (+ 2 x), it's less wanted add 2 if wrote (1+ x). these functions idiomatic in common lisp (e.g., see how increment or decrement number in common lisp?). emacs lisp includes 1+ , 1-.

the language wouldn't suffer if weren't there, reimplemented many times many different people. instance, racket implements add1 , sub1. (also, see add1 function scheme r5rs.)


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

python - How to create jsonb index using GIN on SQLAlchemy? -

-
here's current code creating index jsonb. index("mytable_data_idx_id_key", mytable.data['id'].astext, postgresql_using='gin') but got error. sqlalchemy.exc.programmingerror: (psycopg2.programmingerror) data type text has no default operator class access method "gin" hint: must specify operator class index or define default operator class data type. [sql: "create index event_data_idx_id_key on event using gin ((data ->> 'id'))"] is there way create index on sqlalchemy? the postgresql specific sqlalchemy docs @ http://docs.sqlalchemy.org/en/latest/dialects/postgresql.html#operator-classes mention postgresql_ops dictionary provide "operator class" used postgresql, , provide example illustrating use: index('my_index', my_table.c.id, my_table.c.data, postgresql_ops={ 'data': 'text_pattern_ops', ...
Read more

PHP DOM loadHTML() method unusual warning -

-
i had following code works fine on localhost: $document = new domdocument(); $document->loadhtml($p_result); $form = $document->getelementsbytagname('form')->item(0); // code continues using $form variable after same code updated on outside server, loadhtml() failed , issued warning. warning: domdocument::loadhtml() expects parameter 1 valid path, string given in path/name/to/script.php returned null instead of object code pretty gets fatal error. note contents of $p_result absolutely same on outside server , on localhost. but why displays kind of warning , why not work? doesn't loadhtml() expects argument 1 string in first place? why method expects parameter 1 valid path ? just make clear i'm not calling loadhtmlfile() , i'm calling loadhtml() . thanks. you're affected one of php bugs . issue present in php 5.6.8 , 5.6.9. have affected php version on server, , bug-free version on localhost. the bug forbids null ...
Read more

c# - TransactionScope not rolling back although no complete() is called -

-
i'm using transactionscope rollback transaction fail bool errorreported = false; action<importerrorlog> newerrorcallback = e => { errorreported = true; errorcallback(e); }; using (var transaction = new transactionscope()) { foreach (importtaskdefinition task in taskdefinition) { loader.load(streamfile, newerrorcallback, task.destinationtable, processingtaskid); } if (!errorreported) transaction.complete(); } i'm sure there no transactionscope started ahead or after code. i'm using entity framework insert in db. regardless state of errorreported transaction never rolled in case of error. what missing ? transactionscope sets transaction.current . that's does. wants transacted must @ property. i believe ef each time connection opened reason. probably, connection open when scope installed. open connection inside of scope or enlist manually. ef has nasty "design decision": default opens ...
Read more